Hi Guys, hope you can help me out here. Im in need of some pics of the U-Boat award that is attributed to Juncker, front and back, especially pics of the reverse set up will be most usefull. Hope you can help me out on this one . All the best
-
-
uboat
Is that a Juncker? I thought this was the setup for a Juncker. Maybe we need to talk about both badges now in this thread. JohnComment
-
reverse
reverseComment
-
obverse2
anotherComment
-
Same badge, different hinge. Nothing radical here.
MarcComment
-
badge
Hi Marc,
Gunmount looks different too. Are we sure this is the same maker? JohnComment
-
badge
Could be same, eagle very similar, but in my example, swaz cut out, gun cutout, different reverse, so maybe same maker, just different dies from the same maker?
So we do not have to go back and forth, the other badge attached.
JohnComment
-
reverse
ReverseComment
-
Great stuff! I love these badges. But I think mine just has more hand-finishing.
Comment
-
Juncker
Marc,
IMO, both badges are beautiful, to me, they are in the top three and if you have one (I do not) then it is a super addition to your collection.
The point I am trying to make is that both badges have been called Juncker, here and in other forums. I am not sure anyone has really said that either are for sure Juncker since they are not marked. I believe that one or both have been attributed to Juncker, but not sure what the reasons are except we all like to know who made an umarked badge.
If we are saying they are Juncker, then what are the charateristics that make us believe this, the eagle, pin, hook, exactly what?
For example, I think we could perhaps make a case that your badge has a Juncker hook, and if so, the badge is Juncker. Then, the first badge I posted, since it has the same eagle, is also Juncker, either before or after your badge. I would think after, the more durable hooks replaced the weaker hook. But, I am just trying to start the discussion with a possible lineage of these two badges.
I think both badges stand on their own merits and do not need to be Juncker or anything else, although, it would be nice to know. But, how do we know since I do not think there is a definitive reference for either of these two badges.
JohnLast edited by John R.; 03-06-2006, 12:44 PM.Comment
-
Well, I wish we still had Gordon Williamson here. But here is a long thread with info on Juncker U-boat badges. I think the best we can say is "believed by many" to be Juncker. That belief is mostly on the badge quality and the reverse set-up.
http://gmic.co.uk/index.php?showtopic=466&st=0
Marc
PS - whoever made them, they are rock-solid awesome
Comment
-
badge
Yes, his image matched the one I posted, with the solid gun mount, not the cutout gun mount.
JohnComment
-
I think you are making a bigger deal over hand finishing than it merits. I think it is the same exact obverse.
MarcComment
-
Comment