U Boat Clasps opinions

[MIKE12550]

Hello, I am weeding out the fakes in my collection and need opinions on these
thanks, bb badge #1

[MIKE12550]

Reverse

[MIKE12550]

Hinge

[MIKE12550]

catch

[MIKE12550]

Clasp #2

[MIKE12550]

Reverse #2

[MIKE12550]

Hinge #2

[MIKE12550]

Catch #2

[MIKE12550]

schwerin lettering

[MIKE12550]

other pics

[MIKE12550]

reverse lettering

[Al P]

I do not like either one, the first being unmarked which I am not to sure they even existed (correct me if wrong please) and on the second one the lettering looks wrong compared to known originals.

Al

[MIKE12550]

Al thanks, the first one is unmarked and I dont know if they were ever made unmarked. the second one i tried to post good photos of lettering for evaluation.

[Richard]

I feel the same as Al. I also don't think unmarked examples existed and the lettering on the second doesn't match the originals that I have seen. I would not feel comfortable about either of these.
Richard V

[Jeff V]

Both no good!
jeff