sturmabzeichen real or fake ?

[robert39]

Dear fellow collectors,

I bought this sturmabzeichen through a website and the seller claims it's real.
It arrived today but when I saw it I got a gut feeling that this might be a reproduction.
It does not have a maker mark, if it's real can somebody tell me who made this badge (possible maker) ?
Seller claims it's a type made by Wilhelm Deumer.
Hope other collectors can help me out here.
Thank you.

Greetings Robert.

[Jean-Claude]

Hi Robert,
Wait for other opinions, but I agree with the seller: nice second pattern Deumer ASA in zink with most of the silver finish absorbed by the zink but with beautiful detail in better condition than mine (& much better pictures). Here is mine to compare

I love it

JC

[Thomas Durante]

Hi Robert,

No problems with your new purchase, it is indeed a fine original made by Deumer. Not alot of finish remaining unfortunately, but still a nice original by this maker.

Tom

[Jean-Claude]

Duplicate message, sorry

JC

[Giel VW]

I agree an original Deumer. Probably unworn but even so with a completely faded finish..

[Gorg]

Beautiful one, I like a lot the observe with those very little bubbles of zinc pest. Very good condition!

Greg.

[robert39]

Thank you

Thank you all for your feedback, much appreciated !

[AndyC]

As said original nice badge but the finish is long gone


Andy