IAB-Silver-Part # 2

[TP Alexander]

I am in a quandary. I over-collected in some badges. To be exact:
IAB-Bronze
IAB-Silver
GAB
PAB-Bronze
PAB-Silver

I want to keep one example of each and move the others out to free up some cash for other collecting interests!
I'll put five threads in here and try to describe what I know about them.
I have my favorites, but I would like your input, if I may, concerning these badges.
Condition is one thing. Rarity of maker and anomalies is another.
Which one should I keep as the best representative of it's genre?

For starters, here is the first of three IAB's in Silver. I will include # 4 from the IAB's in Bronze in case I was wrong & it is actually a Silver IAB.

The maker on #1 CW

Thanx in advance for the help.
Tim

[TP Alexander]

# 2 is an f.o.

[TP Alexander]

# 3 has no maker showing.

[TP Alexander]

Here is # 4 from the IAB Bronze thread.
Bronze or Silver?
Maker is FZS.

[Edelweisse]

IAB-Silver

Hi Tim....keep all of them.....I like the "CW"

[TP Alexander]

Yeah, Timmy, I like 'em all too!
But they gotta' go.
The 'CW' was my choice too!
Thanx,
Timmy

[fischer]

Hi Tim

I can't seem to get rid of anything so this would be a tough decision for me.

My advice, sell the other badges and keep all the IAB's...

If I did have to choose just one of these four...I too, would probably select the Carl Wild.
The condition looks to be very nice and the unparalleled obverse design make it a good choice IMO.

But, that Friedrich Orth example look's very nice......

Best Regards, fischer