Hi Guys
I think this thread is a typical example of how confusing discussion based upon picture posting can become.
I was just preparing my respons to Marks statement, quoted by Frank in his last respons. However not to disagree but to completely agree with him.
I'll post to oakleave details of the JFS that clearly show how thick the chrome like finish is applied and is indeed completely obscuring all details. The "tear drop" like concentration on the top off almost every oakleave on this badge would almost lead me to believe that it was hung up side down to dry. As a result the finish migrated a little and was stopped by the oaks outer edges.
So as far as I'm concerned for sure not a thiny applied finish. And here things get difficult. I also have in my collection a couple of PAB's like the Aurich, the A.S (posted earlier) and a Zimmermann (like the one posted by Greg) with chrome like finish. And when it comes to these badge I agree with Frank. The finish is a thin very shiny layer that would easily wear off. But non of these badges have the exact same finish as the JFS.
I didn't try it but I'm damn sure that even with a steel brush you would have a hard time to get the finish off the JFS. It's just not the same. Problem is I can't show it by posting pics you really have to take my worth for it.
Anyway Frank I'm sure we will meet again one of these days and I'll make sure to have the JFS with me for you to see the difference compared to the PAB's
I'll post two scans now of the JFS's oakleaves and I hope these give you an idea of the finish concentration in the upper part of the oakleaves that I tried to describe above.
KR
Philippe
I think this thread is a typical example of how confusing discussion based upon picture posting can become.
I was just preparing my respons to Marks statement, quoted by Frank in his last respons. However not to disagree but to completely agree with him.
I'll post to oakleave details of the JFS that clearly show how thick the chrome like finish is applied and is indeed completely obscuring all details. The "tear drop" like concentration on the top off almost every oakleave on this badge would almost lead me to believe that it was hung up side down to dry. As a result the finish migrated a little and was stopped by the oaks outer edges.
So as far as I'm concerned for sure not a thiny applied finish. And here things get difficult. I also have in my collection a couple of PAB's like the Aurich, the A.S (posted earlier) and a Zimmermann (like the one posted by Greg) with chrome like finish. And when it comes to these badge I agree with Frank. The finish is a thin very shiny layer that would easily wear off. But non of these badges have the exact same finish as the JFS.
I didn't try it but I'm damn sure that even with a steel brush you would have a hard time to get the finish off the JFS. It's just not the same. Problem is I can't show it by posting pics you really have to take my worth for it.
Anyway Frank I'm sure we will meet again one of these days and I'll make sure to have the JFS with me for you to see the difference compared to the PAB's
I'll post two scans now of the JFS's oakleaves and I hope these give you an idea of the finish concentration in the upper part of the oakleaves that I tried to describe above.
KR
Philippe
Comment