AS PAB help please

[hcliffe]

thoughts on this one?

[hcliffe]

2

[hcliffe]

3

[Chet Sowersby]

Harryj,
It's a keeper.

Chet

[Eddie]

I am with Chet,original AS by unknown maker.

[hcliffe]

Thanks guys, any other opinions?

[Thomas Durante]

Hi Harry,

A reproduction in my opinion. Finish is weird, I don't like the base metal look and the hardware is very sloppy compared with originals.

Walk away from this one

Tom

[scott3000]

Im not to Keen on the catch myself

[AndyC]

Hi


Here is mine to compare against
I have only those 2 pictures right now because i am not at home until friday
My pin setup is different compares to yours

Andy

[Levesque]

I agree with Tom , the set up is not quite right on this badge ( catch and hinge) , the weird finish might be from the pictures.
Dan

[scott3000]

My Bronze and silver match Andys

I agree with Tom , the set up is not quite right on this badge ( catch and hinge) , the weird finish might be from the pictures.
Dan

[hcliffe]

Thanks for the additional input. I thought it looked close, but nothing else the seller has looks good so I was concerned. The fakes are getting better all the time.

[Chet Sowersby]

Ouch! Time to retake "Stagmier 101" Sorry for the bad input guys.

Chet

[Eddie]

I made a mistake as well with my comment my apologies

I should not comment when i am drunk

[hcliffe]

Eddie and Chet: No need to apologize to anyone! That's why we are are here! To show recent examples and get input from others. Glad we pulled together and continue to learn about how the fakes are getting better and what to look for.