2 badges oppinion needed

[kaaatinaz]

Dear gentlemen,
can you tell anything good/bad about these two badges?
Thank You.

[ardennes1944]

Hi

GAB

Phil.

[stewy]

ISA pics ain't the best. Possibly an R.Karneth. Stewy

[kaaatinaz]

Sorry, there are only these pictures i have. Here comes 2 not resized pics.
http://keep4u.ru/full/e49802e3529bbd...7c60f3a5c.html
http://keep4u.ru/full/e4bec27b44c392...18ec2aae3.html

[Graeme]

Hi

Welcome to the forum

A couple of points to make you aware of as you are a new member.

We don't like links to other sites, as we often get pop ups we don't want and the thread can become useless if the pics are removed.

Please post direct to this server, and that might mean you paying for membership.

For good evaluation, start as you mean to go on, with good close up pics and in focus.

you will then get a lot of help from the forum members

best regards
Graeme

[kaaatinaz]

Thank you, will do my best to be a good boy
Some new pictures for now:

[Thomas Durante]

Hi Kaaatinaz,

Welcome to the WAF forum.

Both your badges look fine to me, although its hard to see them when they are attached to another hosting site. Posting them in WAF will be better for you to get opinions on.

The GAB is a nice Deumer in my opinion, nice early badge made of brass.

The IAB is also an original, unmarked but thought to be by Rudolf Karneth. Not much finish left, but original.

Tom

[stewy]

Yep,the ISA's a worn Karneth. Thanks for better pics. Stewy

[kaaatinaz]

Thank You, guys, very much!