Heer Flak - RS

[haust]

Hello, Guys.
Excuse for bad photos. To me have suggested to buy this badge and the best photos at me are not present.
Please, your opinions , original or not ?
Thanks, Viktor.

[haust]

[Lubo]

This is a tough one, a hand inspection would certainly help, from here I don't like the fact that somebody played with the file a lot, filing off the wing from the gun barrel, the shape of the eagle's head is not a match (maybe file work again)
Better pics of the hardware (catch and hinge) are needed
There is also a malforming of the wreath (outer side), directly above the gun barrel
What is the weight?

Maaarc,

[stewy]

Lubo,i think it's a wrong'un. I doubt the wing & barrel were ever joined. Good call mate. Stewy

[haust]

The weight is not known. Other photos are not present.
Thanks for the help.
Please still opinions.

[Heer Flak]

I would not buy the badge.

Eric

[fdodge]

This is an interesting badge and I would actually love to see some detailed photos. Based on the photos provided, I would not pay a dime for it.
Frank

[haust]

New photos

[haust]

Rev

[haust]

..

[haust]

...

[haust]

.....

[tgn]

I think it is OK. Who says the wings and barrel have to touch? Souval was such a lack luster manufacturer that the quality of their badges varied greatly from minute to minute and from worker to worker. I would have great doubts in an attempt to identify any consistency in their workmanship.

But heck, that is just my opinion.

However, given the present attempts to document "100%" what is good or bad, you would probably be wise to look for another one that meeets everyones approval. Collecting by popular opinion is the safe way today...

Tom

[bytown]

Do not like the shape of the beak as seen from the reverse.

Although it appears to have the 2 dimples before some of the claws.

Not for my collection.

Wayne