Find the fake badges

[Sergey]

I vote that the person who gets all the answers correct wins all the real badges...how about it fellows?

John

1, 9, 10, 12 I think might be normal.

[Al P]

I wrote these down before seeing the the other answers.

3,4,5,6,7,8,11,13 bad or suspect in my untrained eyes

I cant wait to see how bad I did


Al

[Sal Williams]

Hi Everybody,
Thanks to all of you for participating. Should I let this go on for a little longer or not?
Sal

[Sal Williams]

I vote that the person who gets all the answers correct wins all the real badges...how about it fellows?

John

Hi John,
You are quite the rabble rouser aren't you ! I'm afraid thats only possible if we were to contact the actual owners (I got these from threads on this forum) and ... well... mug them.

[Philippe DB]

Hi Sal,

Before giving the answer, here is my best shot

The fakes are the ones in posts 3,4,6,7,8,11,18

KR
Philippe

[Sal Williams]

Hi Philippe,
I am guessing you meant #13 not #18.
Should I let out the answers? Seems like there are still people in the thread. What to do?
Sal

This quiz is now open to all the moderators and experts as well!

[Ron Birch]

Not an expert by a long shot, but I'll go with 2,3,5,6,7,8,11,13

[mmiller]

Taking a stab at it.

UHHHHHH........

2,3,4,6,7,8,11,13

Mark

[Jack T]

Don't collect badges at all but this looked like too much fun to pass up.

Fakes: 2,3,4,6,11,13

Jack T

[Alex K.]

5,6,7,8,11,13

[Lorenzo Brown]

The good ones are: 1,2, 5,9,10,12

Just being contrary!

[Heer Flak]

I believe 3, 8, 11, and 13 to be fake. I only commented on the Army Falk badges, Pab's, and Gab's since I do not collect the others.
Eric

[Sal Williams]

Answers

Hi All,
Thanks for the good turnout for this quiz!
Here are the answers
#1 Real
#2 Real
#3 Fake
#4 Real
#5 Fake
#6 Fake
#7 Fake
#8 Fake
#9 Real
#10 Real
#11 Fake
#12 Real and my favorite!
#13 Fake

If you guys want another let me know, and vote for a hard quiz or easier quiz if you want another
Best, Sal

[Brian S]

Hi All,
Thanks for the good turnout for this quiz!
Here are the answers
#1 Real
#2 Real
#3 Fake
#4 Real
#5 Fake
#6 Fake
#7 Fake
#8 Fake
#9 Real
#10 Real
#11 Fake
#12 Real and my favorite!
#13 Fake

If you guys want another let me know, and vote for a hard quiz or easier quiz if you want another
Best, Sal

2 and 9 fooled me. I thought they were both bad. 9 looked like it had a lead shine to it. 2 surprises me as real also... Better go check the shoe box of fakes again!

[Sal Williams]

Sal, I can only comment on the army badges. 3,8,11,and 13 are fake. BTW, number 13 is my favorite!

Chet

Hi Chet,
I keep seeing BTW. What does it mean?
Thanks, Sal