Two Hollow PABs, Opinons please

[Dennis GT]

I would like to get some opinions on these two. The one on the left I believe to be a good zinc? F&L in silver. Weight is 14 Grams.
The one on the right that is odd to me. I can not place it. I need your help. Weight is a whopping 22 grams. Hinge, catch & Pin are magnetic.
What can you tell me?

Dennis

[Dennis GT]

Back

back

[Dennis GT]

hinge # 2

hinge

[Don D.]

Hi Dennis, I think the one on the right is trying to be an F&R but its not quite convincing me. The hinge is not one you find on originals, the pin looks funky, and are those casting bubbles i see?

[Chet Sowersby]

Hi Dennis,
As Don said the one on the right is trying to be an F&R. In my eyes it is noticeably larger the good one. I don't belive it to be a casting as castings should be smaller than the badge they are copying and not larger as this one is. I also am not keen on the reverse hardware. In short, I don't care for the badge.

Chet