1 IAB to many, Who's gotta go? You decide!

[Gunner II]

Hello boys

I've been able to trade a dug-up badge for a nice Wernstein made buntmetal solid back bronze IAB. But that created a problem, should I sell this one or the what I believe unmarked S.hu.co bronze IAB I already had in my collection?
Ofcourse I want to keep the best example of the IAB for myself, but I can't make up my mind!
So to keep me from going crazy and to give my wife some rest, I' ve decided to bring this question to you.

Who's gotta go? The Wernstein solid back buntmetal bronze or the unmarked S.hu.co hollowback?

Here are the pic's

Wernstein
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d8...steinfront.jpg

http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d8...nsteinback.jpg


S.hu.co?
http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d8...gap/IABShu.jpg

http://i33.photobucket.com/albums/d8...p/IABShu-1.jpg

Much obliged: Peter

[Mef]

Hi Peter,
if you ask me I would give away the Wernstein solid back buntmetal bronze. The S.hu.co bronze IAB (if that is the maker of this badge) looks in a better shape.

Regards, Mathew

[Master3477]

Hi Peter,
if you ask me I would give away the Wernstein solid back buntmetal bronze...

both badges are zinc badges

[Master3477]

I would keep the hollow IAB

[wh014d4394]

what dug up badge did you swop?

[Philippe DB]

Hi Peter,

No question possible, dump the üü, not really sure about the finish in that badge and like Sven wrote it's a zinker like all üü IAB's.

On top of that the üü is a very common IAB and that for sure can't be said from the second one. Not a Shuco but a very desirable and rare so called hollow "Porsche"

KR
Philippe

[Gunner II]

Thanks boy's
In that case I will keep the " Porche" .I've never know that there was also a IAB that is named "Porche" , I thought only PAB where. I'm very happy with this badge and also that I now know that it isn't a S.hu.co badge wich I thought it was. Are these as seldom as the PAB porches?

I've traded the üü badge for a dug-up wh flakbadge in very poor shape with zincrot disfiguring the whole badge.
Many thanks for helping me making my mind up. At least I can now have some sleep without pandering about wich one gotta go.

Many thanks:Peter