Comments on Partisan badge on e-stand

[jacquesf]

I would appreiate some comment on the partisan badge (Bandenkampfabz. br. with COA ) that is for sale on the e-stand. I want to aquire such a badge for my collection but am totally out of my depth with partisan badges. jacques

[Don D.]

where is it. Post a link.

[jacquesf]

Here is the link http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=141349

[Ludwig]

-

From these pictures it´s hard to tell!

[upbeek]

1

i think that some square on photos would be nice,the ones shown are terrible,it looks like an illuminated version in the first pic?????
chay

[upbeek]

1

1
infact it looks stupid in the pics,better pics needed for sure,
but from what i can tell IT LOOKS LIKE THE MINTEST BKA EVER SEEN????
regards chay

[upbeek]

1

1,new pics added,i would not buy it ,chay

[jacquesf]

Please guys I have had some positive and some negative feedback. Is it possible to get a definitive answer, with some motivated comments Jacques?

[Giel VW]

1,new pics added,i would not buy it ,chay

And why not?

[upbeek]

if i thought it was original with that condition i would have bought it instantly,chay

[Dietrich Maerz]

if i thought it was original with that condition i would have bought it instantly,chay

That is one of the most profound, well thought out, good reasoned and undisputable argumentation for a (possible) fake I've heard in a long time! Thank you for that - we all learned something here...

Dietrich

[jacquesf]

Please guys, this thread is of no help at all, will anybody be so kind to share his expertise on partisan badges .

[Don D.]

I've already provided you with what you need to make a decision.

[Franco]

The most obvious thing about this badge is its finish.These badges were never well made and I have yet to see one that retains as much of its finish as the one here. They started off fairly dull for obvious reasons and have become duller as the years progress.IMO its of recent manufacture.