My Two Italy/Africa Campaign Medals Both Ok?

[Blackopps]

Hi all, Here are my two Italy/Africa Campaign Medals, Both ok?
I think the Bronze one is a Type 2 and the Zinc one is a Type 4 Silber (Silver) Issue. Yes? Thanks for any help. Blackopps










Thanks for looking.

[Steve DT]

The first one looks like a good 2.3, but I'm not a big fan of the 2nd one. It looks like it's trying to be a type 4, but I'd pass on it myself.

[Tom Yanacek]

Hello,

I agree with Steve. The first one is a nice original with a really great ribbon. The second one, unfortunately, looks soft in detail, has too many flaws, and is a cast fake IMO.

Best regards,
Tom

[Antonio Scapini]

I'm with the guys. first is an original type 2.3, second looks a cast fake and I would pass on it.

[Blackopps]

Hi Guys, Thanks for the help and yes the type 4 is a cast fake as I can now clearly see from the photo's that I have taken. Thanks again, Blackopps