Bagged West Wall

[mananero]

Wanna check these out to make sure they are good before I place them up for sale

Thanks in advance

[mananero]

more pics

[Ian Hulley]

Hi, the medals are just fine, the 2 loose ribbons however I feel may be modern reproductions.

Ian.

[Tom Yanacek]

Hello,

The first set (the one with the W. Hobacher packet) is very nice. Medal, packet, and ribbon are all original IMO.

With the second set: the medal looks good, but the Josef Feix Söhne packet is a fake and the ribbon is a modern replacement.

With the third set: the medal looks good, but the ribbon is a modern replacement. The Carl Poellath packet is an accepted original.

Best regards,
Tom

[peterm]

With the third set: the medal looks good, but the ribbon is a modern replacement. The Carl Poellath packet is an accepted original.

Best regards,
Tom

I completely agree with Tom and only want to add that this nice "Buntmetall"-version was not made by "Poellath", these are all zincers.

Kind regards, Peter

[Antonio Scapini]

Hello,

The first set (the one with the W. Hobacher packet) is very nice. Medal, packet, and ribbon are all original IMO.

With the second set: the medal looks good, but the Josef Feix Söhne packet is a fake and the ribbon is a modern replacement.

With the third set: the medal looks good, but the ribbon is a modern replacement. The Carl Poellath packet is an accepted original.

Best regards,
Tom

I can only quote Tom.