SS 8 year legit?

[CurtD]

Gents, your thoughts on this one, please:

[Tony Barto]

Hi Curt;

My personal preference and opinion is that I don't like the piece. It could be the photos, but overall, the quality is poor, the number 8 on the reverse is not shaped the way I like to see them and the swaz on the obverse runs into the rim. Lastly, the bevel on the eyelit is wider than what I like to see.

[keifer kahn]

Im with tony.

[CurtD]

I think the wreath looks a bit fat, too.

[tinmantis]

compared to others in my 'files' the ribbon at the bottom of the wreath is a bit slanted to one side, and the number '8' in kind of flat, rather than smoothly rounded in relief. But, boy isn't it hard!
regards
jon