Memel Medal In A Bag-----Opinions Please

[RonR]

Please give me your opinions of this Memel Medal in a issue bag.

[RonR]

[RonR]

[RonR]

[RonR]

[clevischi]

Its not a model that i would like to owne.

[Peppe864]

I´m not to comfortable with this one either, BUT I am no Memel expert.

[Karsten S]

I´m only comfortable with this version.

Best Regards

Karsten

[Tom Yanacek]

Hello Ron,

The detail on that Memel Medal is lacking in my opinion. I also do not like that issue packet. I remember seeing this same type of issue packet a few years ago on this very forum. Supposedly that particular packet had provenance, but I still don't think they are real.

Best regards,
Tom

[emilitaria_usmc]

the wear on the ribbon and medal don't match
I agree, pass on it

[Darrell]

You could do a Search for Memels. There is a thread with a picture of one Detlev had as fake of the week. It was the same type and dark brown color as yours.

The style that Karsten shows is only one I would want in my collection.

[TABKP]

It a fake.

Picture is taken from site http://www.detlev-niemann.de/