Wehrmacht 4 Year Service Fake Or Real

[elcoleccionista]

Dear Sirs, Any opinion about these two medals: 4 Year Service and West WAll. They seem very real, they can not be twisted by finger, the color is good the ribbon of the four year medal is correct with two holes for the little eagle, which is missing, the ribbon on the west wall medal is fake. The problem with the 4 year service is a line that is in part of the rim due to the casting seam, and the other has not a common color. Any idea? Thank you to all. Carlos

[Don D.]

You need better pics. Try one at a time.

[DOC_KÜSTENART]

the west wall medal looks ok to me, la medalla del muro atlantico me parece buena (I'm not an expert on the other one)
Best regards
Doc

[Robin Lumsden]

They both look original to me.

[elcoleccionista]

Thanks from the El Coleccionista

Thank you for all who replied, Carlos El Coleccionista.

[mrg]

Hi Carlos West Wall looks like late War zinc type, 4 year service looks ok too from those pics. If you are concerned try to post closer pics one at a time. All the best.