long service awards help please

[andya]

Hi
I have no experience of these at all and would appreciate opinions. My own opinion is that the 12 year might be ok and the 4 year bad, but as they are from the same source i suppose it would be logical to take both as bad?
any opinions appreciated
thanks
andy

[andya]

rear

rear

[andya]

3

3

[mrg]

Hi Andy in my opinion i would give both a miss, the 4yr does not look circular and has a poor general shape to it, the 12yr going of the pics looks covered in pot holes and has weak lettering, yet both have good defination to the eagles? Strange so on that alone would not be one for my collection. All the best.