Help with soldbuch

[IlyaB]

please is this man cauld be fallschirmjager?

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...ad.php?t=75164

tnx

[Willi Z.]

Even though based on the Einsatz auf Kreta stamp, I do not think he was a FJ at that time. I do see what appears to be a very late-war entry for a FJ unit, I can not be sure though as I can not clearly read it. He was in a FJ replacement unit at some point, based on the ink stamp in the Ersatz section.

[H BABERT]

Even though based on the Einsatz auf Kreta stamp, I do not think he was a FJ at that time. I do see what appears to be a very late-war entry for a FJ unit, I can not be sure though as I can not clearly read it. He was in a FJ replacement unit at some point, based on the ink stamp in the Ersatz section.

Hi,
in april 44 he was in the fifth FJ division, fit fr paratrooper in march 41, i don't think he was in kreta, or not as paratrooper,but as Willi said, we need better scan of pages 4 and 17 to know more...
Herlé

[Willi Z.]

Ah, I missed a page, now I see FJR13 in 1944.

[Chris]

I think this book has been heavily monkeyed with. I think maybe he wasn't in the FJ at all, and that the FJ entries may have all been done postwar. It is very unlikely that some one would transfer from being a signalist to being a grunt and then to being an artilleryman, for one thing. I've seen a couple dozen FJ signalist books and I've never seen a guy leave the signals branch. A number of these entries look really bogus to me, but the "Einsatz auf Kreta" stamp is completely ridiculous dogshi t. That stamp certainly never existed during the war. I have more than a dozen Kreta jumper Soldbücher, and have seen 40 or 50 more, and that stamp is a bad joke. One of the unit stamps is also clearly bad. This book has "hopped up" written all over it in invisible ink. I wouldn't have this thing anywhere near my collection.

[H BABERT]

I think this book has been heavily monkeyed with. I think maybe he wasn't in the FJ at all, and that the FJ entries may have all been done postwar. It is very unlikely that some one would transfer from being a signalist to being a grunt and then to being an artilleryman, for one thing. I've seen a couple dozen FJ signalist books and I've never seen a guy leave the signals branch. A number of these entries look really bogus to me, but the "Einsatz auf Kreta" stamp is completely ridiculous dogshi t. That stamp certainly never existed during the war. I have more than a dozen Kreta jumper Soldbücher, and have seen 40 or 50 more, and that stamp is a bad joke. One of the unit stamps is also clearly bad. This book has "hopped up" written all over it in invisible ink. I wouldn't have this thing anywhere near my collection.

I agree with you Chris, the stamp "einsatz Kreta" is very strange and probably bogus...
About the fact he wasn't in the fj, we must see better scan, of all the soldbuch, and of these page..; He was signalist, he go in artillery, strange??yes and no, he seems to go in stab of artillery regiment, and it was last days of the war...so...i think we must see more...but no doubt this soldbuch is "monkeyed" as you said...
Herlé

[IlyaB]

Ou! thank you all guys