SS Solbuch Estand

[AJ]

Hi,

this Soldbuch, or at least the "Bandenkampf" entri needs to be discussed:

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=892360

IMO the Bandenkampf entry is fake! Seems as if some one ruined a nice original Soldbuch...

[Edward]

Agree. No BKA days reflected in the Soldbuch. He was only awarded 1 Nahkampftagen in early 1943 during the time the division was still in Russia.

Division was in Greece 1943-44, but am skeptical that the divisional artillery batteries were actually qualified for and given the award.

[Ironcrown]

The entry looks suspicious to me too, because of the stamp, that IMHO is very odd. No Feldpost number on it, why?
However, the price was rather fair for an SS Soldbuch, even without this rare entry!

[AJ]

Well wonder why it was priced fair? I wouldn't want a SS Soldbuch with a fake entry regardless cheap or not...

[Lee Luke]

I am the new owner. The seller pm'd me about the entry first and I agree it is most likely fake. We have met personally in the past when making deals and he has always been completely honest. Craig is a good member of the forum.

[Ironcrown]

That's good!
I don't think there's anything against the seller, just about that strange entry.
I am with AJ, and wouldn't like a Soldbuch with a fake enrty. But it's a matter of points of views... On the other hand, I think that a similar SS Soldbuch with no "bonus" like that may cost 500$ or more