ek1 good or bad

[douglynn]

what you think guys or

[douglynn]

scan2

[German_military]

Hello,
There's a extremily large period between the first medals and the last medal. That's possible, but there must be other things in the book that are also dated atleast much longer after 1943. Is that so?

Was he also still at that regiment at the time?( easy to check if the division is correct) You see that especially at the end of the war they change very quick of regiment.(page 4 in the soldbuch)

In my Soldbucher I see that every "Auszeichnung" is stamped of (like the stamp you see), as a prove that it has been checked.

I don't see that here. Not a good sign... I don't think he really gor the EK1. The germans never forgot such things.


Greetings from Holland,
Frank

[Si1964]

Hi Doug,

My initial thoughts would be to put a question mark against the last entry. But as always will await to hear of the comments from others .

[douglynn]

thanks guys i have 2 boxs one with my likes and 1 with my dislikes while looking at the other thread about books with not many entrys i looked in my dislike box i had forgotten about this one.i only like soldbuchs with awards and pics in sorry but that is my kink.and just looked and saw ek1.yes there does seem to be a gap but there are other dates in 45 entrys if it is fake its a shame as nice awards.

[Gary T]

This one has been on here before...big thumbs down...

[douglynn]

jabs in 45

[douglynn]

i was not sure about this one as i had put one like this before with ek1 entry and bad ss entry but this was gonna be sent back but was bought buy another member i could be wrong if so sorry.he knew about fake award entry

[Bootmanager]

Möglich ? normal fehlt 1 Stempel

Hello, I would not like to deny anything to the soldier. It had a leading by the left ear! For these long patients time, is missing to badges wounded there? The brother of my aunt has the Dk gotten with Cassino, however it was there already death, whom it helps??
..........................................Hallo, ich möchte dem Soldat nichts aberkennen.
Er hatte einen durchschuss durch das linke Ohr ! Für diese lange Kranken - Zeit , fehlt da nicht das Verwundeten Abzeichen ? Der Bruder meiner Tante hat das Dk bekommen bei Cassino , jedoch war er da schon Tod , wem hilft es ??.........

[Matt L]

Hi Doug,

I don't know about this one- look at how alike the letters are and the positioning of the abbreviations in the last two entries... 2 years + later and obviously not done by the same person- and yet they're awfully similar. It sure looks like someone was trying to emulate the previous entry. The ink stamp would be over the original blue entries- can you tell if the final black entry is on top of the stamp or not? Looking at it in reflected light and with a magnifier, you might be able to tell...

Matt

[douglynn]

hi i think this is quite amusing.if i have shown this b4 i am sorry.but take a look at the d in division.and in the next scan take a look at the 4 in44.this book means zilch to me its just a thought that y go to all that trouble.unless the guy put it in for to show his grankidds.this is the third ek1 entry i have had.so far.and i only have one good one lol

[douglynn]

and now the 4 in 44.if he is a forger he aint that good

[Si1964]

Hi Doug,
My thought process was to begin with, from left to right.....

The 4's in the 44 don't not look correct.... The EK script it self looks as if somebody {to me} was try to copy the script about, ironically the last part was squeezed into the top as not to over run the stamp. Similarly the last part again a copy of the above entry but not as clean also the dots placed in between the numerals put be off. As for the signature, well I am sure we have seen hundreds that we cannot decifer, but again I felt it started out as a copy of the above, then just ran away down the page. Now if you see my signature its like a spider in a death throw, but even I can keep it on a straight line .

If my explaination is unclear I will try and copy your scans and still a coiple of arrows in if it helps!!

[douglynn]

yes i think i can hear the twilight zone theme tune???yes i can see what you mean about the k in ek1 bunched up to fit inside the stamp but he made the first k fit in ah well it gives you something to talk about.have a good week end its now 12 30 pm and i have to get my sleep good night

[Si1964]

Doug,

I think we all have some with one or two slightly ify entries in them, quite often a nice SB is slightly ruined with somebody trying to make an extra couple of pounds out of it.

I will dig a couple of mine out.....its not just you my friend