oakleaf 900 godet opinions?

[johnkyens]

Hello guys,I'm interested in this leaf,but I cannot sure whether it is a good one,looking for your opinions

BTW I know there are also many postwar Godet T2 900 21 oakleaves,is there any difference between a postwar one and a pre-1945 one?

Happy Christmas!

[Jelle M.]

A reproduction!

[Thomas Durante]

I can only agree with Jelle, an easy fake.

Tom

[AndyC]

Nope not a good one, sorry for that



Andy

[Dietrich Maerz]

...BTW I know there are also many postwar Godet T2 900 21 oakleaves,is there any difference between a postwar one and a pre-1945 one?

I guess this "knowledge" either comes from Gordon William's book or from Prosper Keating, who also spread this completely false information. In his case more with the intention to ruin the market and elevate his own "knowledge", whereas Williamson more or less just repeated what he had heard. At any rate, this information is false. There are no post-war Godet oakleaves. It is also funny to note that Williamson stated that these alledged restrike of the 1970s are "all but indistinguishable from the original issues." This is funny since if they are indistinguishable how do you know that they are post-war strikes? At any rate, there is not such thing.

[johnkyens]

I guess this "knowledge" either comes from Gordon William's book or from Prosper Keating, who also spread this completely false information. In his case more with the intention to ruin the market and elevate his own "knowledge", whereas Williamson more or less just repeated what he had heard. At any rate, this information is false. There are no post-war Godet oakleaves. It is also funny to note that Williamson stated that these alledged restrike of the 1970s are "all but indistinguishable from the original issues." This is funny since if they are indistinguishable how do you know that they are post-war strikes? At any rate, there is not such thing.

Thanks Maerz for your explain,I know not much about 39 pieces so I found it here www.germandaggers.com/Gallery/OL.php
One of my friends also state that only a Godet pieces are original award ones

Also thanks for all opinions Can anyone explain some characters original pieces ?

[Bek]

Hello, collectors. Here are my leaves. I spent a lot of time studying this subject. I didn't find any defects. Put on some forums, is recognized as the original.