Controversy Ebay oaks

[Peter Wiking]

I have a controversy with a Ebay seller.
I bought what i first trusted would be a 1957 oakleafs. In another thread we concluded that it is a casting and not a 1957 set.

The seller still claims that it is original 1957:
1) EL 1939-45 5.500,00 €
2) 1946-1950 Original Tools used "800" with maker mark 900,00 €
3) 1957-1963 "800" with maker mark, polished Highlights 350,00 €
4) 1965-70 BM vs die forged 120,00 €
nach 1970 BM vs cast variants 60,00 €

What is your opinions?
Peter Wiking

[Larry L]

Send him one of those great pics of yours from that barn find thread
I suggest that "put the crap here"-pic

L

[Blitz]

I agree with Larry.

[Peter Wiking]

How did the seller come to these production years?

1) EL 1939-45 5.500,00 €
2) 1946-1950 Original Tools used "800" with maker mark 900,00 €
3) 1957-1963 "800" with maker mark, polished Highlights 350,00 €
4) 1965-70 BM vs die forged 120,00 €
nach 1970 BM vs cast variants 60,00 €

Thanks.
Peter Wiking

[Peter Wiking]

I wish Gordon could step in and give a few words.

Cheers.
Peter Wiking