Opinions needed on two spanges...

[Robert P.]

I dug these old photos out of the archives. They were never properly ID'ed, and was wondering if anyone could ID them today?

Thank you,
Robert

[Robert P.]

The second...

[streptile]

Hi Robert,

The first is a mystery to me, and was recently shown here. Jon thinks it's a Deumer but I see some differences. Maybe someone could do a side-by-side.

The second is thought to be an early Meybauer, but I think the jury's still out on a definitive attribution.

[Robert P.]

Thank you Trevor,

I was thinking Meybauer on the second myself. Interesting piece.

Robert

[Robert P.]

Hi Robert,

The first is a mystery to me, and was recently shown here. Jon thinks it's a Deumer but I see some differences. Maybe someone could do a side-by-side.

Here you are. The known Deumer on the left, unknown on right...

I see some differences as well.

Robert

[CMSgt]

Spange

The first one looks more like a Meybauer than a Deumer. Here are the three of them - Meybauer, unknown and Deumer. Jim