Several Spange - clasp EK2 Good for you ?

[steiner68]

Hello,

I need your help for theses spange.

good for you or fakes ???

Thank you

[steiner68]

more

1

[steiner68]

more

2

[kriztof]

#2 close up is a bad one for me, sorry to report.

Chris

[Flemming]

#2 close up is a bad one for me, sorry to report.

Chris

I have to agree, and I am not sure about the "Big Eye" either.

/Flemming

[Flemming]

And I would like to see some better photos of number 1 and 4, befoe I would comment on them.

/Flemming

[ben bijker]

1 is an L/18
3 appears to be a good Ziemer

2 and 4 are fake.

ben

[streptile]

1 is an L/18
3 appears to be a good Ziemer

2 and 4 are fake.

ben

I agree but I am not sure about 4. Is it not a good Deumer Prinzen? Or just a fake?

[steiner68]

number

to understand, I numbered the Spange

[Flemming]

There's a strange "blop" on the date bar, on the "Big Eye". I also, based on these pictures, think that the details seems a bit to soft.

/Flemming

[steiner68]

And I would like to see some better photos of number 1 and 4, befoe I would comment on them.

/Flemming

unfortunately, I don't have more pictures...

[Flemming]

The only one I would buy, based on these pictures, would be the first Spange, the one you have numbered "1".

/Flemming

[ben bijker]

I agree but I am not sure about 4. Is it not a good Deumer Prinzen? Or just a fake?

IMO it's the Prinzen of the so-called robot-fake.

[tinmantis]

I'd gamble on just no.1 having a chance at being real, looks like a zinc L/18
2 is a post war souval
3 looks like a cast of a 'bigEye'
4 looks like a prinzen fake

regards
jon

[steiner68]

Thank you!

the first seems to have unanimously, I'll take it and drop the others.

the seller sells a lot of false (for real) but sometimes it falls on good articles.

thank you again for your help

Best regards,

Geoffrey