RK Authenticity

[Marc Garlasco]

Two of the most respected minds in militaria disagree on the originality of the Rounder RK (but that was lost in the silly thread about something else). Please refrain from the lunacy of other posts...

DETLEV NIEMANN, respected expert has stated he believes they are fake.

GORDON WILLIAMSON, respected author stated he believes they are real.

God I wish they would have some coffee and settle this empirically.

Resume lunacy...

[stefan_swe]

How is Nimmergut on RKs?

/Stefan

Two of the most respected minds in militaria disagree on the originality of the Rounder RK (but that was lost in the silly thread about something else). Please refrain from the lunacy of other posts...

DETLEV NIEMANN, respected expert has stated he believes they are fake.

GORDON WILLIAMSON, respected author stated he believes they are real.

God I wish they would have some coffee and settle this empirically.

Resume lunacy...

[Dave Kane]

How is Nimmergut on RKs?

/Stefan

I'll give you a hint Stefan.....

He asserted that the Rounder was the 2nd pattern S&L

[Pieter Verbruggen]

Two of the most respected minds in militaria disagree on the originality of the Rounder RK (but that was lost in the silly thread about something else). Please refrain from the lunacy of other posts...

DETLEV NIEMANN, respected expert has stated he believes they are fake.

GORDON WILLIAMSON, respected author stated he believes they are real.

God I wish they would have some coffee and settle this empirically.

Resume lunacy...

....I will change your S&L for a nice rounder and some extra cash...deal?
Pieter.

PS it was nice seeing you again at the MAX.

[Marc Garlasco]

Pieter,
You are giving me a toothache! Hey - wonderful to see you as well. And what a purchase you made! Thanks for letting me see some real history there.

But I am really serious about my post here. We have such a divisive issue that people get freaking stupid about it and act like children. My Christmas wish is for peace in the Nazi collecting field (odd, huh?) and to get those guys together to bring some kind of understanding. If Detlev says they are fake and Gordon's next book says they are real we will have nothing but continued aggrevation.

Regards,
Marc

[robert60446]

Pieter,
You are giving me a toothache! Hey - wonderful to see you as well. And what a purchase you made! Thanks for letting me see some real history there.

But I am really serious about my post here. We have such a divisive issue that people get freaking stupid about it and act like children. My Christmas wish is for peace in the Nazi collecting field (odd, huh?) and to get those guys together to bring some kind of understanding. If Detlev says they are fake and Gordon's next book says they are real we will have nothing but continued aggrevation.

Regards,
Marc

From my understanding Marc, we should have some answers tonight.

I will post the results starting tomorrow evening.

[MH184]

Right now I'd be happy with any rounder RK, even with all the deliberation and goings on and what ever the results come out as !

You see, I need a justification to buy an RK case, but the wife is of another mind set




Kr


Marcus

[Pieter Verbruggen]

"...guy's you have to believe me, I never gave the order to produce ROUNDERS..honestly...I told Detlev and that's why he knows..."

[Waffen-Mike]

"Oh yes I did give orders to produce Rounders! That other guy, although good looking, is a FAKE!. I hope this clears up this matter once and for all"

[Gene]

I'd go with Gordon; I have seen Detlev err on numerous occasions and besides, I like Gordon's logic better.

[Pieter Verbruggen]

"Oh yes I did give orders to produce Rounders! That other guy, although good looking, is a FAKE!. I hope this clears up this matter once and for all"

....look how small you are, not even the size of a book...and you call me fake...