Krim Shields for review

[Zheleznyi]

Antonio, your opinion is of little interest to us. None of the topics, except arrogance, you did not share.

[Zheleznyi]

http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...94&postcount=2
fake of 70 x - will be written in the originals?
You believe the words, and we only 100% of the evidence.

[Antonio Scapini]

It's hard to find all the evidences if you believe Russia is the world!

You said that shield is fake because surfaced only after the "Breslau" finding. I showed you where to find a 40 years older shield. Fact is that you didn't know the existance of that shield. Why? Simply because you didn't buy a couple of books.
Same with all the Souval production, simply because you never search anything about it.

Are you looking for infos? SEARCH out of Russia.

For example buy period pictures, you will find many interesting infos looking at them! But maybe in Russia pictures are not so important...

Another point: buy a microscope, and you'll see the difference between a fake and a good one simply studying how the metal was stamped.


Last point: can you historically prove, with period documentation and period pictures of the shield in wear, that ALL the shields you consider good are good?
I don't think. But if you can, then start showing some proofs. If you want we can post shield after shield, and you'll show for each one all the evidences you have.

[Zheleznyi]

Yes, I can prove it. And you will not believe, but from the photos too. And not only for them. I even have a microscope Now the bear will examine it and I will begin. I have not only books, but also documents from the Bundes archives that you have never seen.

It's hard to find all the evidences if you believe Russia is the world!

You said that shield is fake because surfaced only after the "Breslau" finding. I showed you where to find a 40 years older shield. Fact is that you didn't know the existance of that shield. Why? Simply because you didn't buy a couple of books.
Same with all the Souval production, simply because you never search anything about it.

Are you looking for infos? SEARCH out of Russia.

For example buy period pictures, you will find many interesting infos looking at them! But maybe in Russia pictures are not so important...

Another point: buy a microscope, and you'll see the difference between a fake and a good one simply studying how the metal was stamped.


Last point: can you historically prove, with period documentation and period pictures of the shield in wear, that ALL the shields you consider good are good?
I don't think. But if you can, then start showing some proofs. If you want we can post shield after shield, and you'll show for each one all the evidences you have.

[Antonio Scapini]

Surely I've never seen them, because I've never made a deep research in this field!
If I ever do one, as for all the rest I've done, I would first spend years in serious researches, not thinking a piece come from the "Breaslau" finding when it was published 40 years before!
I bet you still miss many, many books and researches...

Anyway I'm happy if you can prove everything what you say (hope not in the same way of the "Breslau" finding...)

So please, educate us about this shield.

- Is this original or not?
- Who's the maker?
- What historical evidences have about it?
- Any period picture of this shield in wear?

Thanks for sharing your knowledge.

[Zheleznyi]

Anyway I'm happy if you can prove everything what you say (hope not in the same way of the "Breslau" finding...)

What can you prove about shields from Breslau, except pictures that you do not have anything to do with?

P.S. And then we'll talk about your Narvik

[Antonio Scapini]

You said that shield surfaced only after the Breslau finding.
I proved that shield was around since 40 years before the Breslau finding. And the same shield was also published in '92. This means your statements were pure fantasy. Nothing more.

Now, I would like to see historical evidences for each shield, especially period documentation and pictures. And I'm serious, I'm really interested.

[Stive]

Now, I would like to see historical evidences for each shield, especially period documentation and pictures. And I'm serious, I'm really interested.

Antonio, wait for an exit of reprinting of the book Shields 3 Reich, the book will be added with English translation and documentary photos and other proofs on various shields.