demjanskbattlefield

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Beethoven’s Symphony Number 9, Odes to Joy in Captivity

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Beethoven’s Symphony Number 9, Odes to Joy in Captivity

    In some other thread, I wrote about German prisoners of war bringing Beethoven to Japan. It actually came in 2 phases. The first performance was on June 1st 1918 in the Bando POW camp in Shikoku where they performed for the camp staff and town folk in a gesture of friendship. From these roots came the Japanese tradition of performing Odes of Joy at the end of the year, which is as standard as Silent Night is to Christmas.
    Then I had the luck of personally coming into touch with the second “ first for Japan” performance of Symphony Number 9. Back in 1918, actually, they had not played the whole thing through. So the first ever performance of the second and third movements only came the year after, on December 3, 1919 performed by German POWs of the Kurume Camp in Kyushu, upon invitation from a girl’s school in Kurume. I happened to stumble across a printed program for this day here in Germany and learned from the seller that his wife’s Opa was a Gefreiter in the 1. Komp. III Seebattalion, who was captured by the Japanese in November 1914 and interned in the Kurume camp until December 1919. He came back with tons of photos and when I asked whether he could see any concert photos, out came photos of the historical moment of December 3, 1919!
    The player of the first Violin, Ernst Kluge left a very detailed description of this event in his diary, which was donated recently to the City of Kurume by the son. I was astonished by the sharpness of the photos and how the scene was exactly as had been described in the diary. That morning, 45 prisoners from the camp were escorted by a Japanese Army officer to the school, where the Principle heartily thanked them for coming. He explained that though the school could not afford to pay for the performance, they wished to reciprocate by entertaining the German guests in kind with a martial arts performance by the girls wielding Naginata. After which they were served coffee and cake.
    The concert was quite long but Kluge explains how the girls sat there so politely, hands on their laps waiting in anticipation, and at the end of every score they were given a loud applause. The Germans could not tell, however, whether they were merely being polite or were truly enthusiastic. At the end of the performance, a little girl came up shyly to the German musicians with sheet music and asked whether the orchestra could play Schubert’s Serenade. When the title was written in Japanese on the blackboard by the interpreter for the audience , murmurs of recognition could be heard throughout the hall, and the applause at the end was also correspondingly loudest attesting to the fact that it was a score familiar to the girls. The German recalls this as one of the most pleasant things that came at the very end of their captivity.
    Anyway, the Germans had developed such a bond with the Japanese that a surprising number stayed in Japan until their deaths and two of them were instrumental in showing the Japanese at Asahi Tabi (those tabi shoes that they also wore in WW2) how to blend rubber and to help establish Bridgestone Tires that branched out from Asahi Tabi.
    Here the program for the December 3 Concert printed on rice paper, and another one at the camp two days later.
    Attached Files

    #2
    Finally, a piece that I really enjoy is an illustration book of POW camp life printed for the inmates to take home at the time of release. 29 illustrations capture the highlight moments of life in captivity. The cover and the visit of the night soil man during the morning walks
    Attached Files

    Comment


      #3
      What a mess envy creates when someone gets hold of a Golden Bat (Japanese cigarette)
      The annoying mosquitos during summer nights
      Attached Files

      Comment


        #4
        And the joy of a Hibachi. I can strongly identify with almost all points covered in the illustrations, surprising me how successfully the Germans had grasped the essence of what made them tick.
        Attached Files

        Comment


          #5
          Sorry, I knew I had forgotten something. Here's the concert underway.
          Attached Files

          Comment


            #6
            When I saw these first, it felt as though some legend had come true, an amazing moment.
            Attached Files

            Comment


              #7
              Hi Nick, thanks for sharing. This reminded me about a docu-DVD I watched called “Horror in the East”, they had a short segment on this matter. How the Japanese can treat German prisoner with such kindness in WW1 and then with so much hate and cruelty (towards the Allies) in WW2.
              Here it is on Youtube (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ke5cuKobA1A ), 1:30 into the show.

              Comment


                #8
                Hi Nick, that's a great presentation and result from a chance encounter! The photo's and programme are superb and it must have been a thrill to make that connection!

                Regards

                Russ

                Comment


                  #9
                  What an outstanding find! The photos really bring this bit of history to life.

                  Comment


                    #10
                    [QUOTE=RodneyO;5340431] How the Japanese can treat German prisoner with such kindness in WW1 and then with so much hate and cruelty (towards the Allies) in WW2.

                    Rodney: I thought the same thing. In the short span of 18 years, from the concert in 1919 to the 1937 China Incident, the Japanese attitude towards POWs changed markedly; and tragically.

                    The camp book is amusing; the print called Morgan Spaziergang (morning walk) seems to show the POWs cleaning the latrine. one of the lookers-on has a grimace while the other is holding his nose, evidently standing over a "honey bucket". While the POW tries to sleep with mosquitoes plaguing him the rats are entering the cupboard and the cat is atop the birdcage. I mean, if you are a POW and you have a pet bird things probably aren't too bad as long as you don't get West Nile Virus.

                    Nick, a very interesting connection, learning about the concert then discovering photos and the book.

                    Mike

                    Comment


                      #11
                      They often had more than pets as company. Some wives rented housing in Japan, and lived there throughout the war so they could visit their husbands regularly.

                      They also had their own dentist
                      Attached Files

                      Comment


                        #12
                        They were also routinely allowed to stroll outside the camp in the country side

                        But they had to be at the roll calls at 7AM and 7PM
                        Attached Files

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Here the musicians and our Gefreiter
                          Attached Files

                          Comment


                            #14
                            As easy going as things were, some did escape, disguised as Swedes on visit, making their way back to Germany through China.

                            Regarding the remarkable contrast between these times and WW2, the main reason was that the Japanese were trying hard to be admitted into the company of the world powers of the Imperialists and felt obliged to uphold the 1907 Hague Convention regarding humane treatment of POWs. Also, the Japanese knew that it would be an easy victory against the Germans in China, so the camps were set up well in advance and properly organised. Those were also the days when democracy was being embraced by the population creating an extremely liberal and anti-military mood. Some soldiers even refused to get a military haircut and got away with it. But in the meanwhile, having the victory in the Russo-Japanese war as a tail wind, the Chief of General Staff as adviser to the Emperor started to wield and abuse power, claiming to be above the law as the adviser to a God, etc. And this shift started to put a harsher spin on how the military interpreted its code of conduct, the Emperor's Edict to the Soldiers and Sailors of 1882. I wrote about this in detail in the introduction to the pay books, but it is a highly chivalrous piece of work consisting of 6 principles that soldiers should uphold. Even in this document of noble ideas, however, there was the seed of future barbarism when the Emperor said " Duty was weightier than a mountain, one's life lighter than a feather". The military started to harp on this point more than anything else because they knew the strongest soldier was one that had no fear of death. Then in 1941, fearing that the morale of the army was starting to soften, Tojo added his own contribution to the codes of conduct, which stressed the feather lightness of life by adding one should die rather than face the humiliation of captivity. This allowed the Banzai attacks and mass suicides to occur, a landslide of feathers. "But when ones one life was lighter than a feather, what was the life of an enemy worth, a coward that could not choose honorable death over the ultimate humiliation of captivity?". Through this type of mind control the army drastically changed character. When charges of inhuman activity of the Japanese in China and Philippines were brought against Tojo after the war, he feigned surprise and said those things would have never happened if the soldiers only had been faithful to the Code of Conduct.
                             

                            Comment


                              #15
                              I just watched the "Horror in the East", but their explanation that the Germans were treated as guests because of the standing order of the emperor from 1882 is quite incorrect. That order was the Edict to the Soldiers and Sailors. This remained in force till the end of WW2, so it should have saved the WW2 prisoners as well by that reasoning. Courtesy towards the enemy was one of the 6 codes, but when the part about loyalty and triviality of Life got stressed and expanded to drown out all the other virtues, they were putting words into the emperor's mouth, and like the Crusades, when mortals use God as a puppet of his agenda, things turn savage.

                              Comment

                              Users Viewing this Thread

                              Collapse

                              There is currently 1 user online. 0 members and 1 guests.

                              Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                              Working...
                              X