HELP with Prussian and Bavarian Gunners

[DKNYC71]

Dear Friends,

I would be appreciative if I can get some opinion on these Imperial Aerial Gunners badges. I am not an Imperial badge collector and do not have knoweledge on these badges, hence my inquiry. Many Thanks to all in advance!

Regards,
Dave.

[DKNYC71]

2

[Hagrid]

Sorry again!
The bavarian is a crude cast fake ( wrong hinge-well for Pöllath), the die-struck one is a modern copy.
Regards
Hagrid

[DKNYC71]

Thank you very much Hagrid! much apprecited! A fellow had sent me all these badges along with an RFC wing and a set of Imperial aviation straps to review before making a decision. I am not a WWI Imperial collector and lack knowledge on these badges, which is why I had posted them for opinion here. I had also posted an Austrian pilots badge aand a 'pinzen' airship badge.