medal For the Defense of Odessa Original or Fake?

[Eric Gaumann]

I leave my miss new photos, playing a little illumination of the camera so that you can see better.

The weight of the piece with ribbon and pin included are: 30 grams

It comes to the part that opens this thread are now clearer

This is the same medal in post #1? I think we all agree it is good.
Also, Hola Ruiz?

[gibello]

Ok, thank you very much, the other odessa still I have not received, you will do when I get pictures and if false give it back to the seller, told me that if I can not return good without problems.

Ruiz is a friend of mine who knows a lot more than me in these medals and always ask advice.

thanks

[Ruiz]

Hola Eric...saludos amigo mio!

I think that is original too.

Best regards.

[gibello]

After a long wait, I finally came to my home the medal, I let them take pictures for me, the first medal that started this post, I hope your answer to see if it is an ORIGINAL piece or reproducers.

I have the heavy and weighs 15.8 g

The photographs, put them in different light so that you can better see the details

thank you very much

[gibello]

Any Opinion?

[gibello]

I've been studying this medal, because the seller told me that this is a rare variant that has no top, and I've finally found another just like this but in better shape, I leave the photos I've found that in principle original, but in better shape and both have the same fault, the two medals are missing the upper edge or rim around the top. I think this is a very good sign for me and my medal, although this has worn all the features of the other.





Here the defect edge tell them



And here is mine with the same defect



Hope this helps to clarify this as more difficult and complex piece