I have the Hubert Meyer book, any other good books on the 12th SS?
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
12th SS HJ books
Collapse
X
-
Stephan Cazenave has recently had some good books published about the "HJ" division. Plenty of original material. See further comments here -
http://dev.wehrmacht-awards.com/foru...d.php?t=807839
Comment
-
The Cazenave book on the 12 SS is excellent,far better then Számvéber book which I found to have quite a few mistakes, expensive now though.The point about Amazon is if you put your subject in it comes up with all the books available and usually with reviews so you can make your own mind up about what to buy.
Comment
-
I think that it's a fair question to ask here than rely on reviews on amazon etc. I've always found the reviews quite random and often difficult to distinguish whether the reviewer is on the same page (forgive the pun) as I am. Or the depth of their knowledge on the subject as a reflection of their review ie. someone who has picked up their first TR book and thinks it's fantastic when it's actually a waste of ink and paper.
Generally, those who visit this forum have a similar attitude and passion towards the subject, and their impressions prove far more reliable, and honest.
Apparent laziness can be annoying but on the whole, take it as compliment that someone has deferred to your opinion.
Regards
Allan
Comment
-
Originally posted by Herr Lyppe View PostI think that it's a fair question to ask here than rely on reviews on amazon etc. I've always found the reviews quite random and often difficult to distinguish whether the reviewer is on the same page (forgive the pun) as I am. Or the depth of their knowledge on the subject as a reflection of their review ie. someone who has picked up their first TR book and thinks it's fantastic when it's actually a waste of ink and paper.
Generally, those who visit this forum have a similar attitude and passion towards the subject, and their impressions prove far more reliable, and honest.
Apparent laziness can be annoying but on the whole, take it as compliment that someone has deferred to your opinion.
Regards
Allan
Yeah that is why I asked as most reviews on Amazon are unreliable. people on here have recommend some good books to me in the past so that's why I ask..
I know a lot of guys on here have been studying for years so It's a good place to ask..
If any one has any good English books to add to the list that would be helpful
Comment
-
For a more British-Canadian perspective on fighting the I. SS-Panzerkorps (1. SS-PD LSSAH and 12. SS-PD HJ) in Normandy, with some material from German vets, see Ken Tout's books. These include A Fine Night for Tanks, The Bloody Battle for Tilly, and Roads to Falaise. These are full of exciting first person accounts, while also making clear the horrors of war.
Comment
-
Originally posted by MarcRikmenspoel View PostFor a more British-Canadian perspective on fighting the I. SS-Panzerkorps (1. SS-PD LSSAH and 12. SS-PD HJ) in Normandy, with some material from German vets, see Ken Tout's books. These include A Fine Night for Tanks, The Bloody Battle for Tilly, and Roads to Falaise. These are full of exciting first person accounts, while also making clear the horrors of war.
seems to be old but have good reviews
Comment
-
Originally posted by MarcRikmenspoel View PostI don't have the 40 Hours book, which is his personal memoir, but it is supposed to be very good. All his stuff is either good (that I've read) or well-reviewed (the ones I don't have).
The History of the 12.SS-Panzerdivision Hitlerjugend (1st Edition)
Meyer, Hubert
so got alot to read
Comment
-
If you haven't read it, I'd recommend "Meeting of Generals" by Tony Foster. It is a dual biography of Harry Foster and Kurt Meyer. Foster commanded the 4th Canadian Armored Division in Normandy against Meyer's 12th SS and presided over Meyer's war crimes trial after WW2. The author, Tony Foster, is Harry's son, but both subjects are treated very fairly and the book is extremely well researched. I actually found it more informative than Meyer's "Grenadiers".
Comment
-
Originally posted by Panzer Meyer View PostIf you haven't read it, I'd recommend "Meeting of Generals" by Tony Foster. It is a dual biography of Harry Foster and Kurt Meyer. Foster commanded the 4th Canadian Armored Division in Normandy against Meyer's 12th SS and presided over Meyer's war crimes trial after WW2. The author, Tony Foster, is Harry's son, but both subjects are treated very fairly and the book is extremely well researched. I actually found it more informative than Meyer's "Grenadiers".
Comment
Users Viewing this Thread
Collapse
There is currently 0 user online. 0 members and 0 guests.
Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.
Comment