Warning: session_start(): open(/var/cpanel/php/sessions/ea-php74/sess_a8b3c48f17acee093f769ddcbda71b06de8c6a3e4fc4c7c0, O_RDWR) failed: No space left on device (28) in /home/devwehrmacht/public_html/forums/includes/vb5/frontend/controller/page.php on line 71 Warning: session_start(): Failed to read session data: files (path: /var/cpanel/php/sessions/ea-php74) in /home/devwehrmacht/public_html/forums/includes/vb5/frontend/controller/page.php on line 71 I just don't know what to say... - Wehrmacht-Awards.com Militaria Forums
CEJ Books

Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

I just don't know what to say...

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    I just don't know what to say...

    Sorry if you thought I'd show you an unbelievably mint SS sword or a ton of U.S. items a local veteran has. If you don't like to read or help amateur historians...stop reading now. For the rest of you, I'd really appreciate your input.

    For a small project I'm putting together, I'm trying to interview local veterans. Many of these said men have fantastic stories. Included is a man from Stalag 16, an Anti-Aircraft gunner from the European Campaign, a German machine-gunner turned priest, a Battle of the Bulge veteran who was only 17 at the time, a depth charge technician from a convoy escort ship, and an American armoured infantryman. The problem lies with the last chap.

    Just to tell the spectacularity of his military service, he was wounded three times. The first time an anti-tank round from an 88 grazed his chest. It cut the strap of his M-1 and scarred him both emotionally and physically. The second time he was hit with a ricochet from a bullet. The third time he stepped on a landmine while crossing the Rhine at two in the morning. His battles included Anzio, Operation Dragoon and the following breakout, the Battle of the Bulge, and one other that has slipped me. He was awarded a bronze star for his actions in the Bulge...these actions have caused him to flashback almost daily, get goosebumps if you even mention the star, wake up screaming from nightmares, and eventually become an alcoholic. He was a flamethrower during the landing of Dragoon, but never used it. He was drafted, fought the war so "I could get the hell out of that place", and allowed to leave without fear of the pacific because his points had accumulated so quickly.

    My problem is that I just don't know what to say to him. Everything I'd known of his career was hearsay until one time I caught him in the bar. He invited me to his house, and I did a preliminary interview, but that was that. Since then I've visited once a month or so, but rarely talk about the war. He's just happy to talk to someone other than his live-in son. Over the winter, and the staggering heat of this past July, his health has become increasingly worse. I really need to get a full interview before he is gone, but I'm having a lot of trouble.

    I don't know where to begin with him. The initial interview was roughly a 45 minute tape. He told me the battles he was in, told me how he was wounded, and told me how he came home and started a life. I don't know what specifics to ask him to get him to talk about his life, what happened and how he felt, etc. He has a hard time remembering, but does remember if you mention something. An example; I asked him about trading rations with townspeople and he told me an anecdote about how they used to take cartons of cigarettes, pack the middle with straw, and leave a pack on either end. By the time the townspeople found out, they were long gone. I've thought of asking his son for some pictures, his medals, his souvenirs, etc. to jog his memory, but I fear his son is more concerned with his father's health. Is there any list of questions prepared by the government? I've heard they have database scouts killing for veteran interviews. Are there any questions you guys could help me with? Time is the problem, and I just can't think of what to ask.

    If you're going to answer with "He probably doesn't want to talk" then you are mistaken. Many of my father's friends who know him closely say when he's drunk he will tell about the Bulge, and the Bronze star. He's repeatedly told me that he will try to tell me "anything you want to know."

    I really appreciate any help you can be, this past year I have lost a great uncle who was a veteran of D-Day and a liberator of a concentration camp, a Marine who was my neighbor for almost 10 years who said "The only time I left the farm was to go overseas, and there's nothing I wouldn't do to change it." and a waist gunner on a B-17. I shouldn't lose another one, and with your help maybe I won't.

    Respectfully and desperately,
    ZaCK

    #2
    What if you started by asking him to describe (as best he can) his day to day life while he was over there? Then if something came along that was fascinating, you ask for more details of that one moment maybe?

    The trouble is finding his trigger. Maybe you should start with numerous "openers". If one doesn't do it, go to the next one?

    Comment


      #3
      The easiest way to get a guy talking is to start asking about the guys he was with. Ask who his best bud was. ask if his close friends got through all right. Ask about his squad members. This will usually lead to I remember when Him and Me Went, Got, Had, and you will go to many topics.

      Comment


        #4
        Zack, Library of Congress has had a Veterans History Project for about 5 years now, where they try to collect oral history either from veterans directly or through volunteers. They have an interview kit. I used to know a girl who did this here in NYC but I never actually looked at the kit, so no clue as to how good it is - but its probably worth a try.

        http://www.loc.gov/vets


        Most of my encounters with veterans have been within the context or psychotherapy/counseling sessions, kind of hard for me to give you pointers as the dynamics of an interaction in that setting are quite different from just talking to someone over a beer. It is quite an experience though, as I am sure you already know.
        Last edited by Vadim K; 08-04-2005, 11:52 PM.

        Comment


          #5
          Here is a basic layout for an interview Veterans History Project suggests

          Segment 1: For the Record:

          Make an introductory announcement at the start of each audio or video recording. Record on tape the date and place of the interview; the name of the person being interviewed; his or her birth date and current address; and the names of the people attending the interview, including the interviewer and his or her institutional affiliation or relationship to the interviewee and the name of the camera or recording operator if different than the interviewer. Ask the veteran what war(s) and branch of service he or she served in, what was his or her rank, and where he or she served.

          Segment 2: Jogging Memory:

          Were you drafted or did you enlist?
          Where were you living at the time?
          Why did you join?
          Why did you pick the service branch you joined?
          Do you recall your first days in service?
          What did it feel like?
          Tell me about your boot camp/training experience(s).
          Do you remember your instructors?
          How did you get through it?

          Segment 3: Experiences:

          Which war(s) did you serve in (WWI, WWII, Korea, Vietnam, the Persian Gulf)?
          Where exactly did you go?
          Do you remember arriving and what it was like?
          What was your job/assignment?
          Did you see combat?
          Were there many casualties in your unit?
          Tell me about a couple of your most memorable experiences.
          Were you a prisoner of war?
          Tell me about your experiences in captivity and when freed.
          Were you awarded any medals or citations?
          How did you get them?
          Higher ranks may be asked about battle planning. Those who sustained injuries may be asked about the circumstances.

          Segment 4: Life:

          Ask questions about life in the service and/or at the front or under fire.

          How did you stay in touch with your family?
          What was the food like?
          Did you have plenty of supplies?
          Did you feel pressure or stress?
          Was there something special you did for "good luck"?
          How did people entertain themselves?
          Were there entertainers?
          What did you do when on leave?
          Where did you travel while in the service?
          Do you recall any particularly humorous or unusual event?
          What were some of the pranks that you or others would pull?
          Do you have photographs?
          Who are the people in the photographs?
          What did you think of officers or fellow soldiers?
          Did you keep a personal diary?

          Segment 5: After Service:

          Appropriateness of questions will vary if the veteran had a military career.

          Do you recall the day your service ended?
          Where were you?
          What did you do in the days and weeks afterward?
          Did you work or go back to school?
          Was your education supported by the G.I. Bill?
          Did you make any close friendships while in the service?
          Did you continue any of those relationships?
          For how long?
          Did you join a veterans organization?

          Segment 6: Later Years and Closing:

          What did you go on to do as a career after the war?
          Did your military experience influence your thinking about war or about the military in general?
          If in a veterans organization, what kinds of activities does your post or association have?
          Do you attend reunions?
          How did your service and experiences affect your life?
          Is there anything you would like to add that we have not covered in this interview?
          http://www.loc.gov/vets//questions.html
          Last edited by Vadim K; 08-05-2005, 12:07 AM.

          Comment


            #6
            Maybe you should get a little drunk with him, and let him talk about the bulge and stuff.

            I also do veteran interviews. But some guys dont want to talk, other start crying, its not always easy. Most arent about to start saying how they remember shooting a certain German, and seeing him dying, or similar things.
            JL

            Comment


              #7
              Hi Zack, Vadim's post is very useful and you will not go wrong in using thse questions.

              A drink with a Veteran is a good idea. A few beers will often help

              Cheers, Ade.

              Comment


                #8
                Thanks a lot for everything guys, more help is still appreciated. The problem with a "few beers" is that while he's still sober, I'm starting to wish I had poured my last couple on the ground.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Hello Zack,

                  Sounds like you are working on a very interesting project. Hopefully you can get the information from this veteran that you need. Vadim has some very good ideas! Maybe you can use this also.
                  http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/books/oral.htm#whatisoralhistory This is the web site for the Center for Military History, and the link is for an e-book titled ORAL HISTORY TECHNIQUES AND PROCEDURES, this book is full of all kinds of useful information concerning interviewing veterans.
                  Hope this helps,

                  Charlie

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Hey Zack -

                    A beer or two is fine, but some of this man's health problems probably stem from his alcoholism. I second most of the advice above, but I would try to do short interviews rather than one or two drawn out ones - it will save your liver, too.

                    I have interviewed Vietnam era vets on several occasions, and it is really striking how many fothe same "triggers" work no matter what the era.

                    Don

                    Comment

                    Users Viewing this Thread

                    Collapse

                    There is currently 1 user online. 0 members and 1 guests.

                    Most users ever online was 10,032 at 08:13 PM on 09-28-2024.

                    Working...
                    X