Opinions on 1938 & later Brotbeutel?

[John A.]

Hi, I thought I had a really good breadbag nailed down not long ago, but
after getting it verified here, when I went to buy it, it was gone...

I've found 3 more, one of which I have to wonder about.

I checked both the "equipment "sticky" and the very old thread that preceded it, but found nothing on these.

1 is a 1938 which is missing a leather strap in the interior. Also, the
leather strap inside looks pretty dry and stiff. I'll post pics, but
assuming it's ok, does the early date make it more desirable than
a later one in better condition? (Pics of those coming also.)

Thanks in advance for any opinions you can offer, and any information about
the relative desirability of the 1938 breadbag vs. the others!

All the best,
John

[John A.]

More pics

Next pic is last one for the 1938, and then the next breadbag is shown.

[John A.]

Third breadbag pics here...

Thanks again, all, for your help!

John

[jonni]

number 3 ist postwar west german...

[anmarlodz]

Nr 1 and 2 are wartime ; first pre war second prewar/ early war made. Nr 3 as mentioned postwar.

[John A.]

Thank you very much!!

Thanks very much for your help! I sincerely appreciate it!!
Thanks for confirming my fears about the postwar one!

All 3 are the same price, and all 3 are listed by the same seller as WW2 German.

If one could only have 1 original Brotbeutel, would you consider there to be a
significant difference in the desirability of the 1938 one, vs. the other original one?

Thanks again, and all best wishes to you!

Sincerely,
John

[anmarlodz]

If I would need to pick one, I would take the mint one.