SS generals collar tabs, opinions please

[Bond]

I've had these for a few years and I'm sure their wrong, but thats what this forum does, educate us.
They were overpainted with silver/grey which I removed, as well as possible.
They are velvet, and behind the backing fabric is a layer of cork!!!
Thanks, and I wont be too dissapointed if their wrong.
JerryBB

[Bond]

And the backs.

[TomH]

wrong!

Your instincts are right - these are not even close

[bwanek1]

Well, how do you think they compare with the originals you found while searching this forum?

[Bond]

Thanks

I did say I thought they were wrong, but I did think that not all of us have the knowledge of others, so I posted them. SS is not my area of interest, though it is interesting and I merely asked to confirm my own conclusions.
Mostly I have trop stuff and heer/km/lufty insignia, but over the years I have aquired a number of related items and without the time/motivation to engage in proper research, the forum seems like the right to post such items. Some of these items, if found to be correct after posting on the forum, might well be used to fund items I am more interested in.

Your input is valued and I thank you for taking the time to post your answers.

With thanks, JerryBB

[CurtD]

Well, let's wait and see what Manzie has to say....

[PMan]

Tabs

Well, let's wait and see what Manzie has to say....

Curt,
If you use the forum search function, there are plenty of original SS general rank collar tab examples for you to examine. I would think you would know that buy now instead of waiting for me and others to evaluate the tabs for you.

[CurtD]

Curt,
If you use the forum search function, there are plenty of original SS general rank collar tab examples for you to examine. I would think you would know that buy now instead of waiting for me and others to evaluate the tabs for you.

But you have a unique perspective.

[Jack D.]

"One more pip would have put it over the top!"

That's a bunch of work!

Jack

[Bob Coleman]

Poor quality reproduction.

[Military]

Not even close.

[AFF96]

Ditto here...