Warsaw getto uprising?

[Gran Sasso]

Perhaps the above photo was even taken at this event:
http://www1.yadvashem.org/yv/en/exhi.../august/06.asp

Great work - I am sure now my foto was taken during the same event in 1942.

Although I am sure some army-units took part in the 1944 ghetto-uprising, the people shown here look to well-dressed and -feed.

[Edelweisse]

Picture

Hi,

Yes...there were many Wehrmacht units in the 1944 Warsaw Rebellion..

Oberfeldkommandantur 225
Ostpruessen Grenadier Reg 4
Wachregiment 'Waschau' - Oberst Lange
Alarmregiment 'Waschau'
Landesschuetzen Batt. 996
Landesschuetzen Batt. 997
Landesschuetzen Batt. 998
Armee-Panzer-jager-Abt 743
Panzer Zestorer Batt 654
Pioneer Batt 654
Baupioneer Batt 66
Baupioneer Batt 146
Baupioneer Batt 737
Sicherungs Batt 944
7 Genesungs Komp
Feldgendarmerie Komp 225
Feldgendarmerie Komp (mot) 914

Based upon "WARSAW 1944 - Poland's bid for Freedom" by Robert Forczyk dated 2009

Based upon the picture..I'd say that it's prior to 1944.....plus the Polish Resistance wore "Red & White" armbands

As a note: I own SS-Obergruppenfuehrer Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski's Preliminary Award document for the German Cross in GOLD

[Ohlau]

units took part in the 1944 ghetto-uprising

What ghetto-uprising in 1944 ???

Ghetto-uprising in Warsaw was in 1943....

And M-36 tunic wasn't the most wearing tunic during 1944 Uprising....

[besslein]

units took part in the 1944 ghetto-uprising

What ghetto-uprising in 1944 ???

Ghetto-uprising in Warsaw was in 1943....

And M-36 tunic wasn't the most wearing tunic during 1944 Uprising....

i have seen m36 tunics used in 44 warsaw problem

[Admiraal]

units took part in the 1944 ghetto-uprising

What ghetto-uprising in 1944 ???

Ghetto-uprising in Warsaw was in 1943....

And M-36 tunic wasn't the most wearing tunic during 1944 Uprising....

1943? it started 1 Aug. 1944.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw_Uprising

[Admiraal]

Hi,

Yes...there were many Wehrmacht units in the 1944 Warsaw Rebellion..

Oberfeldkommandantur 225
Ostpruessen Grenadier Reg 4
Wachregiment 'Waschau' - Oberst Lange
Alarmregiment 'Waschau'
Landesschuetzen Batt. 996
Landesschuetzen Batt. 997
Landesschuetzen Batt. 998
Armee-Panzer-jager-Abt 743
Panzer Zestorer Batt 654
Pioneer Batt 654
Baupioneer Batt 66
Baupioneer Batt 146
Baupioneer Batt 737
Sicherungs Batt 944
7 Genesungs Komp
Feldgendarmerie Komp 225
Feldgendarmerie Komp (mot) 914

Based upon "WARSAW 1944 - Poland's bid for Freedom" by Robert Forczyk dated 2009

Based upon the picture..I'd say that it's prior to 1944.....plus the Polish Resistance wore "Red & White" armbands

As a note: I own SS-Obergruppenfuehrer Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski's Preliminary Award document for the German Cross in GOLD

Thanks, but Panzer-Grenadier-Ausbildungs-Bataillon 5 was fighting there as well.
http://www.lexikon-der-wehrmacht.de/...fErsBat5-R.htm

[Matthew]

.....

1943? it started 1 Aug. 1944.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Warsaw_Uprising

You're mixing up two different events
Warsaw ghetto uprising was in 1943
Warsaw uprising was in 1944

cheers
Matt

[Ohlau]

Warsaw ghetto uprising was in 1943
Warsaw uprising was in 1944

Correct !

Please do not mix up two different historical events.

[Steve P]

Warsaw ghetto uprising was in 1943
Warsaw uprising was in 1944

Correct !

Please do not mix up two different historical events.

I'm sure it was an unintentional mistake on behalf of the poster!

[anmarlodz]

Great work - I am sure now my foto was taken during the same event in 1942.

Although I am sure some army-units took part in the 1944 ghetto-uprising, the people shown here look to well-dressed and -feed.

first of all ; warsaw ghetto uprisng was in 1943 !!! rember that !!
in 1944 was WARSAW UPRISING - it was made by Armia Krajowa ( Polish Home Army ) - the polish restitance !!

In Warsaw TWO uprising took place :
- 1943 - Jewish Warsaw Ghetto uprising
- 1944 - Polish Home Army ( Armia Krajowa) Warsaw uprising
Those are two diffrent Uprisings.

DO NOT CONFUSE THOSE TWO UPRISINGS !!

THIS is primary mistake made by any Western citizen - you simply see no diffrence between those uprisings.
It is very sad !

[anmarlodz]

Hi,

Yes...there were many Wehrmacht units in the 1944 Warsaw Rebellion..

Oberfeldkommandantur 225
Ostpruessen Grenadier Reg 4
Wachregiment 'Waschau' - Oberst Lange
Alarmregiment 'Waschau'
Landesschuetzen Batt. 996
Landesschuetzen Batt. 997
Landesschuetzen Batt. 998
Armee-Panzer-jager-Abt 743
Panzer Zestorer Batt 654
Pioneer Batt 654
Baupioneer Batt 66
Baupioneer Batt 146
Baupioneer Batt 737
Sicherungs Batt 944
7 Genesungs Komp
Feldgendarmerie Komp 225
Feldgendarmerie Komp (mot) 914

Based upon "WARSAW 1944 - Poland's bid for Freedom" by Robert Forczyk dated 2009

Based upon the picture..I'd say that it's prior to 1944.....plus the Polish Resistance wore "Red & White" armbands

As a note: I own SS-Obergruppenfuehrer Erich von dem Bach-Zelewski's Preliminary Award document for the German Cross in GOLD

You are showing data and units used in WARSAW UPRISING in 1944 NOT Warsaw ghetto uprising in 1943. You confusing two completely diffrent events !

In Warsaw ghetto uprising were used mostly SS and Police units - no larger army units !

And guys on photos ARE NOT POLISH RESITANCE - no one from polish resistance would talk with german soldiers or commanders ! they would shot each other if they would met !

[Admiraal]

I´m sorry, yes i did confuse the 2. I didn´t know there was a separate uprising by the ghetto in 1943.

[Edelweisse]

Warsaw

I also apologize...I do know the difference and the events. My mistake...heat of the moment.

[Matthew]

.....

And guys on photos ARE NOT POLISH RESITANCE - no one from polish resistance would talk with german soldiers or commanders ! they would shot each other if they would met !

Now thats a bit of a exaggeration- there are numerous photographs proving the contrary- one showing Bor Komorowski capitulating to Bach Zelewski comes to mind but there are others. On the other hand "Resistance" was what Stauffenberg was doing. We had underground country with all the trappings of one -including schools, newspapers,theaters, courts, government and the biggest underground army in occupied Europe.
But that of course has nothing to do with the picture in this thread so my apologies
cheers
Matt