U-Boat opinions

[Marc Garlasco]

All,
Two badges I would appreciate opinions on:

Lots of flash on that deck-gun




An interesting reverse on this one:

[rhudspith]

The spange looks like a good 1st pattern with the dished back, these are pretty rare, especially in silver.

Regards
Rob

[Philippe DB]

Hi Marc,


Both badges look just fine to me. The flash arround the deckgun is quiete typical for this unknown maker and the exampleWeitze had in his update today is absolutely stunning.

The clasp looks ok too based upon these small pics. For me the difference between a good and a bad U-Boot spange is best visible in the little eagle and the detailing there is impossible to juge on such small pics. On the other hand I can't image Weitze making a mistake here. Also if I'm not mistaken it was Gordon who once stated that these first pattern spanges to the best of his knowledge weren't copied yet.

KR
Philippe

[Frank Heukemes]

IMO both are fine and very desirable.