Krim Shield from unknown maker

[kraut72]

i give up,everybody believes in it in which wants

[Spaten]

May be I am blind
Is this two dates identical?

Andrei, on the shields shown by Pascal too there are differences.
One of them fake?

[andrei1774]

Andrei, on the shields shown by Pascal too there are differences.
One of them fake?

First of all I would like to make it clear, I never say this type is fake , I said questionable."Yes, this type of shield are questionable in Russia" and about your shield I said "Is it fake, bad light, different die, different press I do not know, but differences exist IMO"
Now about dates on two Pascal's shields. I didn't see a lot differences, actually more similarity. All die flaws similar.

[Antonio Scapini]

The differences Andrei are due to the light, for me too both shields were made from the same die. We can consider also that a strike of the die can be lightly different in strenght from another, so some die flaws can be more or less evident.

[andrei1774]

I am with the Kraut72, I just gave up.......everybody has rights to have their own opinion.

[HeinzGrimberg]

Gentlemen,
I like this shield, but I know that some consider it as a fake. In Russia for example...
What your opinion?
Thanks.

Hi, Mr. Stapen

Did you buy it that?

I remember when this item was for sale.

http://www.militaria-berlin.de

Krimschild auf Heeresstoff

Best.-Nr.: 5832

It is my opinion. The site has a very high reliability.

Do not worry about it.

Best regards
S.W

[Militaria-Berlin]

Also, comparing photos taken at different angles, with different light and camera equipment is totally unprofessional IMO.

You need to identical photos or scans of the said shields to do a half way correct comparision.

MB

[Bruce Simcox]

Hi Guys......

...... IMHO all the shields shown here are identical, and from the same die, with the badges all being made by the same manufacturer.

[Spaten]

Gentlemen,

Here a photos with other lighting....